Multiple-choice 6, 7 and 14 and short answers 12 and 15: Multiple-choice 6 asked for the name of the line linking expected return to beta (the security market line), 7 asked for a CAPM cost of equity (25.8%) and 14 asked which statement is NOT a CAPM assumption (that investors have different expectations). Short answers 12 and 15 asked for the capital asset pricing model and the arbitrage pricing theory. Read the sections on the CAPM formula and the arbitrage pricing model.
Multiple-choice 7 and 8: Question 7 gave a Treasury bill rate of 15%, a market return of 21% and a beta of 1.8, and the CAPM answer is 15% + 1.8 × 6% = 25.8%. Question 8 gave a recent dividend of ₦3.00, a cost of equity of 15% and growth of 5%, and the value is 3.00 × 1.05 ÷ (0.15 − 0.05) = ₦31.50. Read the section on the cost of equity.
Multiple-choice 8: Abolore Limited paid a recent dividend of ₦3.00 a share, has a cost of equity of 15% and expects constant growth of 5% in earnings and dividends. The expected share value is 3.00 × 1.05 ÷ (0.15 − 0.05) = ₦31.50 (option C). Read the section on constant growth.
Multiple-choice 9 and 10 and short-answer 13: Multiple-choice 9 asked what marks a successful acquisition in the long run (ICAN’s key: an increase in the market price of the acquirer’s shares over what it would have been). Question 10 asked which merger motive makes the most economic sense (economies of scale). Short-answer 13 gave AB Limited (5 million shares at ₦64) acquiring XY Limited (2 million at ₦35) by shares at market values; the answer is 1,093,750 shares. Read the sections on acquisition or internal growth, and the share exchange example.
Multiple-choice 11 and short-answer 9: Multiple-choice 11 asked which is NOT a direct source of finance to SMEs in Nigeria from microfinance banks, the Central Bank of Nigeria, the Bank of Industry, co-operative societies and friends and relatives (ICAN’s key gives the Central Bank). Short-answer 9 asked for the problem small firms face in obtaining bank loans under the 5Cs of lending (collateral or security). Read the sections on the financing problem.
Multiple-choice 13 and 20: Question 13 asked which source of finance is known as vendor credit (ICAN’s key gives hire purchase) and question 20 asked which factor is not significant in choosing short-term or long-term borrowing (the key gives the yield curve). Read the section on term and commitment.
Multiple-choice 15: Adeoye Plc (quoted) has a P/E ratio of 20. Moonshine Limited, which is not quoted and is similar in all respects, has after-tax earnings per share of ₦1.50. The value of a Moonshine share is 20 × ₦1.50 = ₦30.00 (option D). Read the section on the P/E ratio method.
Multiple-choice 17: The question asked which item is NOT part of a complete financial plan. The options were a detailed profile of all management staff, clearly stated strategic, operating and financial objectives, the assumptions on which the plan is based, a description of the underlying strategies and contingency plans for emergencies. The answer is the profile of all management staff. Read the revision list and the order of working.
Multiple-choice 18 and short answers 4 and 17: The multiple-choice question asked for the measure of how well the returns of two risky assets move together (covariance). The short-answer questions asked for a combination of securities giving the highest expected return for a given standard deviation (an efficient portfolio) and for the correlation of two projects that are completely and positively linearly dependent (+1). Read the sections on covariance and on the efficient frontier.
Multiple-choice 19: The question asked which is NOT a method of raising capital from existing and prospective shareholders from offer for subscription, tender offer, rights offer, offer for sale and stock exchange introduction. The answer is stock exchange introduction, because it raises no new cash. Read the section on the methods of raising equity.
Strategic Financial Management · May 2014
Every objective and theory question in this paper, and the topic notes to revise each one.
May 2014 diet
1 objective and 7 theory| No. | Section | Marks | Covers |
|---|---|---|---|
| Q- | Governance questions: The May 2014 paper asked in the multiple-choice section which stakeholders governance aims to p... | ||
| Q1 | The 15-mark compulsory question asked for the value of Wazobia Limited by three methods and two limitations of each. ... | ||
| Q2 | The 15-mark question gave two identical companies that differ in capital structure and asked what an investor holding... | ||
| Q3 | The May 2014 paper asked (15 marks) why a quoted company would want to know the make-up and objectives of its shareho... | ||
| Q4 | The 15-mark question noted that annual reports are seen as important but that share prices do not react in the short ... | ||
| Q5 | The May 2014 paper asked (9 marks) how the aim of maximising firm value can be compromised by conflicts between manag... | ||
| Q6 | Question 6 included a forward discount calculation, with the dollar at a discount of about 3.7%. Practise the premium... |
Objective questions Section A
Theory questions Written questions
Governance questions: The May 2014 paper asked in the multiple-choice section which stakeholders governance aims to promote and what is not required in a well governed entity (question 3: board members need not hold the most shares), and asked in the short-answer section to name the processes by which companies are directed and controlled (corporate governance). Read the sections on composition and the role of the board for the points behind those answers.
Short-answer 5: Short-answer question 5 tested interest rate parity. Practise the forward rate formula and the worked examples on IRP and part-year rates.
Short-answer 13: AB Limited (5 million shares at ₦64 and EPS ₦4.00) intends to acquire XY Limited (2 million shares at ₦35 and EPS ₦2.50) through an offer of shares at current market values. The shares to issue are 35 × 2,000,000 ÷ 64 = 1,093,750. Read the section on the purchase consideration and worked example 1.
Revise this question
The board: roles, composition and committees › Composition of the boardExchange rate relationships: PPP and interest rate parity › Interest rate parityFinancing acquisitions and mergers › The purchase considerationThe 15-mark compulsory question asked for the value of Wazobia Limited by three methods and two limitations of each. The model answer adjusts three years of profit (inventory error, directors’ pay at ₦1,875k and depreciation at ₦3,000k), averages them to ₦4,050k and applies an average peer P/E of 6 for ₦24.3m. Break-up value is ₦29.725m. Dividend yield at an average 10% on ₦2.25m gives ₦22.5m. The examiners said performance was poor because candidates did not understand the valuation methods. Read the sections on asset-based and income-based valuation.
Revise this question
Business valuation: asset-based and income-based methods › Income-based valuationThe 15-mark question gave two identical companies that differ in capital structure and asked what an investor holding 4% of the geared company should do to improve income or keep it, and then the effect of a ₦50m loan on the cost of capital under MM with tax. The model answer uses V = V_U + Dt (₦280m + ₦62.5m × 30% = ₦298.75m against a market value of ₦312.5m), sells the overvalued geared shares, borrows personally and buys the other company’s shares. The examiners noted that fewer than 30% attempted it. Read the section on MM and arbitrage.
Revise this question
Financing projects and capital structure theories › Modigliani and MillerThe May 2014 paper asked (15 marks) why a quoted company would want to know the make-up and objectives of its shareholders, and five advantages to the finance manager. The model answer gives avoiding agency conflict and decisions that follow shareholder preferences, with advantages for dividend policy, risky investment, financing, resisting a takeover, performance measures and the religious beliefs of shareholders. Read the sections on stakeholders and shareholders.
Revise this question
Corporate governance: meaning, concepts and stakeholders › StakeholdersThe 15-mark question noted that annual reports are seen as important but that share prices do not react in the short term to their publication. Part (a) asked for the EMH, its forms and the empirical support (5 marks). Part (b) asked for the implications for technical analysis (charting) and for fundamental analysis (5 marks). Part (c) asked for two roles of portfolio managers in an efficient market (5 marks). About 60% of candidates attempted it and performance was fair. Read the sections on the three forms and on the implications.
Revise this question
The efficient market hypothesis › The three formsThe May 2014 paper asked (9 marks) how the aim of maximising firm value can be compromised by conflicts between managers and other stakeholders. The expected points are the agency conflicts on this page: effort and reward, little incentive for creative ventures, high salaries and perks, empire-building through mergers, diversification that protects managers, a short-term view and actions that reduce creditors’ wealth. Read the sections on agency conflicts and on reducing the agency problem.
Revise this question
Agency theory and other governance theories › Agency theoryQuestion 6 included a forward discount calculation, with the dollar at a discount of about 3.7%. Practise the premium and discount rules in the section on forward rates.